The trumpet is just a fad...




NEW YEARS RESOLUTIONS SALE

Through 2/15/2012, save 25% on all instructional courses with coupon code RESOLVE2012. Learn more

I got a copy of a letter today written back in 1921.  It made me laugh and I thought I would share it.  I am tempted to share it with no comments because it speaks for itself, but underneath the letter below, I will pontificate a bit.

A quick bit of history first.  The writer of this letter was Herbert L. Clarke, a famous bandmaster and cornet player.  He was writing to Elden Benge, who became a notable trumpet player and the founder of a company that built trumpets to this day.


MPTB1.jpg

So when is the last time you listened to a cornet solo?

I like reading this kind of stuff because it makes a point very well that we all need to remember.  That point is this: If you condemn innovation just because you are not comfortable with it and don't understand it, you are eventually going to look pretty foolish.

No one needs to hear this more than some that fight for tradition and against progress in church music.  This fight is not new.  In fact, as I read this letter, I was reminded of Martin Luther using similar language when describing the organ.  At the turn of the 20th Century, people felt similarly about using the piano in church.  Today, the fight is about drums or rhythm or any number of other things.

Here is reality.  The fight in Christian music has been far more about cultural preferences and comfort levels than many will admit.  That is not to say that there are not legitimate concerns about worldliness, association, and appropriateness.  But, too often, people pontificating on these issues are heavily biased toward what they are used to.



Will you do me a personal favor?
If you use Facebook, please take a moment and comment on this post. I appreciate the feedback and doing this helps other people learn about my resources. Non-Facebook users can leave comments using the alternate form below.


Lenny






Janet D.






Ed Paine






Daniel Lamb






Greg






Michael Mullen






Greg






An interested reader






Leave a Comment


Name:
Website:
Email:
Comment:
Verify Code:  
Image Validator

Want a FREE lesson from Greg?

Download a 75-minute free instructional video for free with no catches. Greg discusses how church pianists can learn how to play mood music during quiet times in the service. Go here to learn more.